By taking on a job in the professional art industry you are bound to run into contradictory feedback throughout your career. It is normal, it is common and it is something you will have to get used to over time.
The contradictory feedback you receive from different parties in your studio or company can leave you confused, unsure of what feedback you should take into consideration. This is where the role of the “hierarchy” comes into play, helping you decipher who has the expertise to properly critique and what you should ultimately incorporate in the finished project.
This will help guide your creative process, showcasing your ability to take feedback and turn it into a satisfactory project for your company.
To deal with feedback successfully, it is to your benefit to create a positive working relationship, learn how to respond to feedback (good or bad), and to work with your art director in order to get the job done.
Remember, you are working in an industry where feedback is necessary. You are creating something based off of someone else’s vision, so it is crucial that you can bring that to life using your artistic talents and skills.
Understanding Contradicting Art Feedback and The Hierarchy
Depending on the industry your career is in, things can look different for you in terms of feedback. There are often many different people telling you many different things, which can lead you to feel confused and overwhelmed in response.
To differentiate the conflicting feedback you receive, it is important to understand the hierarchy of a company and how they all work together to create something. The main person who overviews you is most commonly your art director, someone who is in charge of supervising and unifying the entire vision of the project you are completing. They are valuable and their feedback is something you should listen to and implement into your work. Your art director will help you to communicate things visually, giving you the chance to bring the main idea to life using your skills. Your art director is someone you should always be looking to and working with throughout the artistic process.
Other higher-ups, such as a director (in film) or a designer (in gaming) can have input that may be valuable to you, but it is about analyzing their artistic instinct and expertise. Since art isn’t their mastery, sometimes you may need to pick apart their suggestions and see what will make the most sense for the project at hand.
For example, if you were working in video game design, you may be asked to change the color of something due to its purpose or functionality in the game. This is important feedback and something that will be necessary to fix so that the entire project is cohesive with the designer’s end goal.
But, if this same designer tries to give you feedback on background design or characters, it’s probably more important to listen to your art director because that is where their specific expertise lies.
In your career, feedback is something you need to be able to differentiate and understand to reap success. It might take time, but it is something you will eventually get used to. Stay in tune with the hierarchy, understanding their needs and the importance different parties play in the projects you are completing. Stay true to the vision you are creating, using your talents and skills to guide you through the feedback you receive.
The Importance Of Art Feedback Boundaries
It is also beneficial to maintain boundaries within the hierarchy to respect the intent and creative effort of the artist. As the artist, it’s important for you to understand where the feedback is coming from and how to use it to your advantage. You must be able to get to the root of the issue at hand and figure out how to resolve it successfully.
For example, an art director may give you simple instructions so that you can follow their lead and fully understand the gist of the feedback they are giving you. They will express the main goal in a creative manner so that you can better understand the current project.
In the same sense, higher-ups may give similar feedback but they may not relay the message properly since art is not the center of their expertise. This is why it is crucial that you can distinguish what feedback is valuable and how to use it to create your company’s desired vision.
An art director will dig deeper, giving you more to work with through their feedback and recommendations. They know how every detail plays a role in what you’re creating and their expertise in this field can help guide you through the creative process. While a higher-up may have good intentions, they might not have the certain expertise needed to give influential feedback.
This is why boundaries play a significant role in this industry, regarding the feedback you receive and how you use it in what you’re creating.
Using Other’s Artistic Feedback As A Helpful Tool
If you are receiving proper feedback, you can use this as a tool to guide your creative process and help you through your artistic journey with every project you take on.
Listen to your higher-ups when necessary, seeing that you are tailoring to their ideas and the vision they want to see finalized. Use their professional expertise to guide how you approach the project and the process you utilize artistically.
Take your art director’s expertise into consideration too, knowing that they understand the creative side of the entire vision and can point you in the right direction towards creating a successful and satisfactory final project for your company.
All of the feedback you receive in your career can have a significant impact on how you create, the skills you use, and the process you take to finalize the completed project. It can influence small details, large details, and everything you put into what you create.
Use feedback as a way to get a better understanding of your work, how to complete it proficiently, and bring your company’s ideas to life.
As long as you keep the vision at the center of what you create, you are bound to be successful!
Feedback, Your Art, and You
To deal with contradictory feedback, you should try your best to fully understand how to differentiate the good and the bad. This will play a role in how you analyze critiques from different audiences and use them to create a satisfactory finished project for your team.
Once you can distinguish the difference in the types of feedback you receive, you can then begin to incorporate boundaries between your artistic abilities and the hierarchy of higher-ups within your company.
You are valuable, putting your artistic talents and skills into everything you create. Your art director is important, helping guide the creative process for you and bring the overall vision to life. The higher-ups (directors, designers, etc) are helpful, giving you the main idea to work with while sharing their expertise through the entire project. Everyone plays an important role in the process towards meeting the end goal for the team.
All of the opinions, ideas, and forms of feedback are necessary to create a successful final project. To use this to your advantage, you must be able to distinguish how certain feedback will either help or hurt the project you are working on.
Remember, you are developing something for a company and you are bringing their vision to life. You are responsible for taking their ideas and creating something out of them. This is no small task but it can be accomplished as long as you maintain a positive working relationship and use feedback to help you succeed while working with your art director and higher-ups to get the job done.
As an artist, you are given the freedom to follow your creative process but in this industry, you have to constantly take feedback into consideration. Think of it as a tool and use it to help guide you through the process, so that you can complete the project successfully and satisfactorily.
Prove that you can bring any idea to life, using feedback as a way to gauge your entire artistic journey!
The art you create and the feedback you receive will work hand in hand, giving value to your career and the future you can build in this industry. Educate yourself, stay up on your skills and use feedback to finalize projects in order to build success through everything that you create.